Taylor
Swift and Ryan Adams may be singing the same words, but their styles are
drastically different, and this changes their overall message. Swift’s powerful
message and voice come through throughout her entire song, strong and
unrelenting. Her message does not apologize for coming through, and her lyrics
are simply delivered in an “I don’t care” kind of way. This, paired with her
use of multiplying her voice really bring forward the importance of how she is
interpreting the end of the relationship. This in comparison with Adams softer,
acoustic version of the song really bring to point the difference in
interpretation. Adams starts off with a broken voice, his lyrics being
delivered as if he is simply listing his grievances, in a cathartic way.
Taylor
Swift’s edition of Bad Blood is
clearly not to be interpreted as apologetic in any sense of the word. Swift
starts the song off right away with no background music, enforcing the
importance, not of the music, but of her own message. She is powerfully taking
about the cuts she was delivered, and this is given in a revengeful type of
way, where she is demonstrating her anger at being mistreated. This is
drastically different than Ryan Adams’s version, which is much more tame. Her
delivery, too, is accented by heavy drums, only further enforcing the message.
Ryan Adams’s
version of Bad Blood is soft and
completely in tune with his background music – guitar. This is really important
in contrast to Swift’s use of silence in the beginning of her rendition of the
song. Adams really starts out making it “prettier” in the context of sound. His
voice, too, is wholly different than Swift’s as well. Listening to Adams sing
gives an impression of a downtrodden soul attempting to work his way through a
bad break-up. This can be demonstrated by his use of the lyrics “You say sorry
just for show,” wherein he drifts away, almost in lamentation (2:16). This is
important to note in contrast with Swift’s delivery of those same lyrics.
Samantha,
ReplyDeleteI did the same analysis of a song that you did. I really like that you pointed out the absence of music in the background of the beginning of Swift's version- great analysis!
Great analysis, didn't think of how Taylor started off the song right away getting her message out right away. We have similar views tho on how Taylor's song is more powerful while Ryan's is more calm and soothing.
ReplyDelete